Friday, 16 March 2012

Is mineral oil dangerous? Part 1


Mineral oil gets quite a bad rap... why? We're going to take a look at the most common reasons people give for why you should avoid mineral oil this week in a 2-parter:



1. Mineral oil comes from crude oil... I'm not putting gasoline on my face! - FALSE


While it's true that mineral oil comes from crude oil, it doesn't mean that its properties are the same, or even similar to gasoline!

Crude oil is formed when biological material (from algae and plankton) gets buried under the sea. Over millions of years, the pressure transforms the carbon-containing compounds in the once-living tissue into the carbon-containing compounds which make up crude oil.

Crude oil contains of lots of different things, mainly made up of carbon and hydrogen only. After it's been pumped out of the ground, it has to be refined to separate out the different bits.

Apart from mineral oil and gasoline, things that come from crude oil include paraffin wax (found in most candles, and in cheese wax) and asphalt/bitumen. And as you know, candles and gasoline and asphalt are completely different! So just because it comes from the same stuff at the beginning doesn't mean it'll look, act or be the same.

Separating mixtures of chemicals is actually very interesting - there's a brief introduction here.



2. Mineral oil is full of carcinogens, using mineral-oil containing creams is going to give you cancer! - PARTLY TRUE

Crude oil contains a lot of different things, and some of them are quite carcinogenic (cancer-causing)! If you're trying to separate it out into different products, it has to be done carefully to make sure you get the nasties out. In fact, the World Health Organisation classifies untreated or lightly treated industrial-grade mineral oil as known carcinogens, and there are many studies linking inhalation of industrial-grade mineral oil to various cancers. However, the stuff in your cosmetics and in the food aisle is of a different grade, and has been purified to remove carcinogens.

A similar situation is with castor oil. I like to use castor oil as an example, because it's something that natural skincare advocates use without thinking twice, but its story is quite similar to that of mineral oil!

Castor beans (technically seeds) come from the castor oil plant:


They look harmless enough, but they contain ricin, a deadly poison - 1.76 mg will kill an average adult, if injected or inhaled (that's about as much powder as you can squeeze on the head of a pin). Eating 5-20 of these beans will kill you, in a very painful way.

However, these seeds also contain castor oil, which after processing to remove the toxins is completely harmless, on your face or in your stomach (except if you drink too much, in which case it does what any oil will do and makes you poop like crazy). It makes no sense to me why some natural companies tell you to stay away from mineral oil, but are perfectly fine with castor oil, if they don't trust that separating chemicals is effective.


The reason so many people are instinctively against mineral oil seems to be because of a widespread misconception that natural = good or at least won't hurt you, man-made = toxic, which simply isn't true! Every chemical, man-made or natural, should be assessed on its own merits - which is a pain in the butt compared to the much simpler formula above, but a lot more sensible. If you missed it, I made a post last year on natural vs. chemical, which explains my position on the subject.


Does mineral oil work for you?


Tune in for Part 2 Sunday/Monday depending where you are!

18 comments:

  1. Can't wait for part 2! I used to use Bio-Oil on my face before reading about how bad mineral oil was for you. You've explained everything much better than anything I have read though :-)

    I don't use bio-oil anymore but did find good results when I did. I now used MooGoo products instead.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! I think different things work for different people - mineral oil is ok for my cheeks but if I put it on my T-zone, it becomes an oil patch! I'm glad to hear it worked for you, from what I've heard it seems to be quite good for a lot of people who aren't as shiny-faced as me :)

      Delete
  2. This is a good post, I had ENOUGH of the fear-mongering on mineral oil.

    Mineral oil is GOOD and is probably one of the safest cosmetic oils we can use.

    Plus, mineral oil is NATURAL.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree! I'd extend it to fear-mongering on EVERYTHING - microwaves, Vaseline, GM foods, just to name a few of my pet peeves!

      Delete
  3. I dont get why people make such a big of a deal with it, if it would be so bad it wouldnt be on the market, right?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think there's a lot of misinformation being passed around about it - some things on the market are dodgy, but usually not the ones people pick up on! Lavender oil, for example, isn't too good for you, but you don't see massive campaigns against it...

      Delete
    2. Lavender Oil SHOULD get the bad rap. Apply lavender oil and go out in the sun -- let's see what happens.

      Delete
    3. It's also alleged to give little boys boobs!

      Delete
    4. Paula Begoun says lavender kills skin cells - is that true?

      Delete
  4. Love yr posts and cannot wait for part 2 - thanks for keeping us informed :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Interesting. I'm fairly skeptical about scare mongering, but I have to admit I do make (half-hearted) attempts to avoid mineral oil. Now I'm wondering why.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I do too... but only because they make my already-oily face look like an oil slick. My face and occlusives = not-bffs.

      Delete
  6. Hey Michelle, I linked your two posts on Mineral oil to my mini serie on Chemicals in your Make up, they are very well written xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you fellow scientist! :)

      Delete
  7. Hello,

    Interesting post..But I partly agree with you. It is not a battle of between natural and chemical, but more wat it is good for the skin.
    Mineral oil has not benefits for the skin. It just creates a barrier and do not necessarly let skin breathing. Instead, why not replacing with olive or jojoba oil which bring so many good nutrients for the skin?
    At the end of the day, it is a bit like cooking. I love cooking with excellent ingredients. The same for skincare. I do want results for the skin and I know I will not get it with beauty products that contain mineral oil.
    Mineral oil is used as a cheap filler for so many cosmetic companies. I am french as well, so I know that all the big luxurious companies use it...but you pay so much money for it. Hilarious.

    Have a great day!

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for commenting! I read every single one :) No spam please.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...